Position management is one of the most overlooked skills in trading. The shiny new entry setups seem to proliferate our social media channels, while position management receives little airplay.

Yet it can be what separates a trader who rides price moves with clarity on when to take action, from one who repeatedly watches their unrealised profits simply vanish.

In this article, we break down both sides of position management — scaling in and scaling out — and explore practical ways you can blend these tactics into your existing strategy.

 

What Are ‘Scaling In’ and ‘Scaling Out’?

Scaling in means opening your full intended position size in planned stages instead of all at once when you first see a potential set-up. This allows you to test your idea with smaller risk first, then add size as the trade proves itself. Done well, it’s like gradually moving with the “market breath” as it shows evidence of a continued move.

Scaling out means taking profits off in “chunks” as the price reaches certain levels — locking in some realised profit gains rather than waiting for an all-or-nothing technical exit. Through banking gains progressively, you also reduce risk, leaving less at the mercy of the next Truth Social post or sentiment-changing event.

Why Do This?

At first glance, this may sound unnecessarily messy. Why not just get in and get out — keep it clean?

Real markets rarely move in a straight line, even with the strongest of trends. Trends invariably develop in waves, and reversals can often happen quickly, irrespective of instrument or timeframe.

 

Benefits of Scaling In

• Risk Control: By starting small, you’re not overcommitted too early. If the setup fails, your loss is smaller.
• Confirmation: Adding when a trend continues to be confirmed helps align your exposure with demonstrated market momentum. Price action is king, and this should dictate what we do and when we do it.
• Confidence Booster: Committing in smaller steps feels less intimidating, particularly when combined with a trail or scaling-out strategy.

 

Benefits of Scaling Out

• Lock in Cash Flow: Taking some profit at logical points locks away real money while giving the rest of your position room to run, helping overcome any feeling of fear of missing out – FOMO — as discussed in a recent article.
• Reduces Pressure: We have all seen a big open position profit swing back. Donating your profit back to the market this way places you in a high-stress situation. Further trading decision-making may be less sharp as a result. Such stress is far less if you’ve already banked part of your profit, and you gain confidence from a good decision. 
• Flexibility: You’re not forced to perfectly time the absolute high or low. You capture the ‘meat’ of the move in stages. The time when a trade is most likely not to continue in a desired direction is right at the very start of a trend, where we often see false breakouts, or near the end, where momentum is starting to drop. Why not take advantage of this?

 

Errors with scaling (how you can mess it up) 

The potential benefits of scaling in and out are clear; however, you can still run into issues if you misuse them.

Here are three scenarios where many traders may see it fail:

1. Averaging Down: Adding more to losing positions, hoping to ‘get back to break-even,’ is a classic but not uncommon trap. Scaling in should always be based on the underlying concept, adding to price move strength, never to weakness.
2. Random Additions: Adding size just because a trade is profitable, without clear levels or criteria for action, often backfires. It can lead to scaling at the wrong time or overdoing the next scale in lot size, as overconfidence takes over.
3. No Clear Plan: Many traders who believe in the scaling out concept have every intention to do so, but in the absence of clear criteria. Having an unambiguous, specific price action-based approach is vital. Without such guidance, trading logic may be easily replaced by emotional decisions. 

Like all parts of your trading, the best results are usually obtained through articulating this part of your strategy within your written plan.  Constantly adjusting scale-in or scale-out points mid-trade causes overthinking and inconsistency. The whole point is to reduce second-guessing with what to do and when to do it, not add more.

 

Examples of ‘Scaling In’ Approaches

Example 1: Break-and-Retest approach

Scenario: A resistance level breaks decisively.

Action: Enter 50% of your planned size at the breakout.

Confirm: If price pulls back and holds above the broken level, add the remaining 50% on a bullish confirmation candle.

Why: You get initial exposure early, but most size goes in once you have more evidence that the breakout is valid.

Example 2: Trend Building approach 

Scenario: In a clear trend with identifiable pullbacks.

Action: Enter the initial lot size on the setup confirmation. After a retracement pullback, add more on a breach of the recent pre-retracement swing high. 

Why: Rather than dumping all your capital at the first sign of pause (and there are signals which may indicate this is likely a pause rather than a reversal), you are riding the trend leg by leg, using market structure to guide your positioning.

Examples of ‘Scaling Out’ Approaches 

Example 1: Predefined Profit Milestones based on risk

Example: Plan to take off 50% at 1R (one unit of risk) or an ATR multiple and trail the rest over breakeven

Why: You secure a profit cushion while letting the remaining position run for higher returns.

Example 2: Approaching Known Levels

Example: Scaling out just before major resistance levels for longs (or support levels for shorts).

Why: Price often reacts to previous price consolidation levels. Taking partial profit nearby locks in gains before potential reversals. Market participants observe these levels, and there may be limit orders that may cap the likelihood of a move through the next key level.

Example 3: Weakening Momentum

Example: If you see a slowing on momentum indicators (e.g., smaller histogram bars or signal line histogram cross) or reversal candle pattern on a smaller timeframe, close a portion rather than the whole trade.

Why: If you’re wrong about the trend ending, the remainder might still offer further upside benefit.

Tips for Mastering Scaling

Here are three underpinning principles to help you master scaling:

1. Always plan scale points before you enter a trade — not on the fly.
2. Never add to losing trades. Scale in only as confirmation builds and criteria are met.
3. Journal your trading: Compare the results of trades with and without scaling to see its impact. Make this an ongoing exercise to offer some evidence to refine your initial system.

Final Thoughts

Scaling in and scaling out are not the holy grail, but if acted on well, are sharp tools for traders who want to manage trades that are in tune with the underlying market.

Handled with care, they help you ride trends more smoothly, protect open position profit, and reduce the mental anguish every trader can face when the market moves unpredictably in a fully open position.

The bottom line is you don’t need to catch every pip or point, just enough to make sure that you give yourself a better chance to grow your account consistently than you may be doing now.

Ready to start trading?

Try free demo Open account